Published December 20, 2025 Category: Mike Matthews

Why do auto transport quotes vary so much?

Learn why car shipping prices fluctuate and how to compare auto transport quotes without getting scammed.

Why do auto transport quotes vary so much?

auto transport car shipping auto transport quotes how to compare car shipping cost per mile trusted car shipping broker reviews

Why do auto transport quotes vary so much?

You want to ship a car. You go online. You get five different prices. One is $800. One is $1,200. One is $2,000. It makes no sense. Most people think shipping a car is like buying a toaster. It is not. It is a volatile marketplace.

I am Mike. I run logistics here at AMG Transport Co. I also see the carrier side through our parent company, AMG Endeavors. I know why the numbers move. I also know that if a quote looks too good to be true, it is a lie. This industry is filled with fraud. You need a guiding light. Here is the truth about why your quotes are all over the place.

The Broker vs. Carrier Dynamic

You cannot usually call a carrier directly. They are on the road. They are dealing with traffic, DOT inspections, and broken tie-down chains. They do not want to talk to you. They do not want to explain how door-to-door car shipping works. They want to drive.

Carriers rely on brokers like us to handle the front end. We deal with the sales. We handle the coordinating. We manage the backend systems. More importantly, we protect both sides. Carriers fear getting stiffed on payment by individuals. Brokers ensure they get paid. On the flip side, some carriers know they can overcharge a regular person who does not know the market. A good auto transport broker in Texas keeps rates reasonable by knowing exactly what a route should cost.

Factor 1: The Equipment Used

How your car travels changes the price. This is the biggest divide in quotes.

Open Car Carrier Transport Cost

This is the standard. Most cars move on a multi-car trailer. It is exposed to the elements. It is the most affordable way to ship. If you have a daily driver, this is what you want.

Enclosed Auto Transport for Luxury Cars

If you have a classic or an exotic, you pay more. Enclosed trailers protect the car from rain, rocks, and dust. The capacity is lower. The insurance is higher. When you ask about enclosed carrier benefits for exotic cars, you are paying for peace of mind.

| Service Type | Typical Cost | Best For |

| :--- | :--- | :--- |

| Open Carrier | Lower | Daily Drivers, SUVs, Used Cars |

| Enclosed Carrier | Higher | Luxury, Classic, Exotic |

| Inoperable | Extra Fee | Cars that do not roll or steer |

Factor 2: Supply, Demand, and the Route

Distance is not the only thing that matters. What affects car shipping cost per mile? It is the route density. Shipping a car from Houston to Los Angeles is a common route. Many trucks move that way. If you are shipping from a tiny town in North Dakota to a farm in Maine, expect to pay a premium. The driver has to go out of his way. That costs fuel and time.

Timing also matters. If you need a 72-hour pickup window, that costs more than a flexible schedule. The market changes weekly. A vehicle could be anywhere in the country at any point. We find the truck that is already there.

Factor 3: Vehicle Size and Weight

An SUV takes up more space than a sedan. It is heavier. Weight increases fuel consumption. This is why you see a shipping an SUV vs sedan cost difference. If you have a modified truck with a lift kit or large tires, you will get a higher quote. It takes up the space of two small cars. Be honest about your vehicle specs. If you lie, the carrier will just refuse the load when he arrives.

Factor 4: The Low-Ball Quote Trap

This is where people get hurt. Some brokers use automated software to give you the lowest possible price. They do not care if a carrier will actually take it. They just want your deposit. Then your car sits for two weeks. Then they call you and say, \"Good news, I found a truck, but it costs $500 more.\"

That is not how we work at AMG Transport Co. We give honest quotes. We vet our carriers. We check their insurance. We use VIN scans to make sure the right car gets on the right truck. We use Stripe for secure deposits so your money is safe. We are a Texas based auto transport broker with a nationwide reach, and we do not play games with your time.

How to Choose a Reliable Auto Transport Broker

Do not just look at the price. Look at the reputation. Check trusted car shipping broker reviews. Ask if they have experience with multi-car transport for families or luxury vehicle transport. You want someone who knows both sides of the mirror.

At AMG, we act as the buffer. We handle the people problems so the drivers can focus on the road. The roads are dangerous. Drivers have enough to worry about. We make sure the carrier is invested in taking care of our clients. We have the relationships to make things happen when other brokers fail.

Conclusion

Your car is one of your most expensive assets. Do not trust it to the lowest bidder who won't answer the phone. You need an experienced car shipping broker you can trust. You need someone who knows how to move a car from coast to coast without hidden fees.

AMG Transport Co. provides the customer experience you deserve. We coordinate everything from door pick-up to delivery. We use vetted, insured carriers. We provide a 72-hour pickup window and honest pricing from the start. We do what carriers don't want to do, so you don't have to deal with the headache.

If you want the job done right, stop guessing.

Get a quote from AMG Transport Co. here.

Written by Mike Matthews, Logistics Manager at AMG Transport Co.

View this article with full site experience